Can Royale Business Club survive tax evasion case?



Is Royale Business Club guilty of tax evasion?
Yes, according to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) as the agency filed a P359.75 million tax evasion case against the popular popular multi-level marketing (MLM) company.

royale-mlm-bir-tax-caseAccording to the BIR, Royale “willfully attempted to evade or defeat tax” and “deliberately failed to supply correct and accurate information in its annual income tax returns and quarterly value added tax returns” in the past three years 2011, 2012, and 2013.
The BIR said Royale’s aggregate deficiency tax liability during the three-year period has reached P359.75 million, inclusive of surcharges and interests, broken down as follows:

  • Tax liability in 2011: P135.87 million
  • Tax liability in 2012: P115.39 million
  • Tax liability in 2013: P108.49 million

The BIR’s complaint stated that Royale Business Club earned muti-million peso income deposited to the company’s bank accounts that were heavily understated in the company’s Income Tax Return filings.
For example, the company’s bank accounts in BPI, BDO and Metrobank showed that the company allegedly received combined income deposits of P190.79 million in 2011, P236.38 million in 2012 and P354.06 million in 2013.
However, the BIR said that the company declared only the amounts of P39.14 million in 2011, P106.69 million in 2012 and P196.68 million in 2013 as gross sales in its Income Tax Return, hence the tax liability. (See table below)

 Gross Sales (deposited in Royale's BPI, BDO and Metrobank accounts)Gross Sales (declared in Royale's Income Tax Return)Tax Liability of Royale Business Club (as computed by the BIR)
2011P190.79 millionP39.14 millionP135.87 million
2012P236.38 millionP106.69 millionP115.39 million
2013P354.06 millionP196.68 millionP108.49 million
TOTALP781.23 millionP342.51 millionP359.75 million

Included in the tax evasion charge sheet were the following executives and employees of Royale Business Club:

  • Julius Allan Nolasco – President
  • Isa Angela Bautista – Vice President for Finance
  • Jeanette Maghirang and Imelda Pedron – Assistant Treasurers
  • Marjorie Molina – Assistant Accounting Manager

According to the BIR, members of Royale do not face the same tax evasion charge because the deficiency was a tax liability of the company, not the members.
Still, members must prove they paid the correct taxes from the commissions earned from Royale, otherwise, they could also be guilty of tax evasion, according to BIR Commissioner Kim Henares.
Royalé Business Club is a networking firm / multi-level marketing company manufacturing and distributing food supplements, cosmetics, and pharmaceutical products. Its headquarters is located at Royale Centre 1363A Quezon Avenue, West Triangle in Quezon City.
Do you think Royale Business Club will be able to win this tax evasion case? Let your voice be heard and join the poll below!
See also: Royale discussion thread in the PMT Forum

About the Author

PSEi support seen at 6,200 and 6,000 amid weaker Peso

In a not-so-surprising move, the U.S. Federal Reserve (Fed) yesterday raised interest rates by 75 basis points (bps) or 0.75% in a bid to tame rising inflation in the United States. This was the third consecutive 0.75% rate hike by the Fed, which brings the federal funds rate, the central bank’s benchmark interest rate, to ... Read more
blank

Official SWIFT Code of BDO, BPI, Metrobank, Philippine banks

When sending cash remittances or wire transfer to a bank account in the Philippines (such as BDO, BPI, Metrobank, Landbank, DBP, etc.), you’ll surely need the SWIFT Code of the bank. Look no further because you can find all the SWIFT Codes you need in this list! Make sure you’re using the right bank code ... Read more
blank

How to Waive your Credit Card Annual Fee (BDO, BPI, Metrobank, RCBC, Citibank, UnionBank)

Without a doubt, one of the most annoying fees that credit cardholders have to pay is the annual fee. Majority of cardholders are familiar with this fee and majority of us likely pay this grudgingly year after year after year. In the case of my credit card with BPI (Bank of the Philippine Islands), I’m ... Read more
blank

Why Filipinos do not become business owners or entrepreneurs

For a majority of Filipinos, entrepreneurship does not seem to be a typical, expected path. This is not surprising, considering that in school, students are primarily taught to become employees after graduation. Students train for years to become staff workers, reporting to a supervisor, and just waiting to receive their wages or salaries every month. ... Read more
blank

My experience investing in Mutual Funds in the Philippines

I started investing in mutual funds when I was 22 years old. As an Overseas Filipino Worker (OFW) then, I was fortunate to be able to save some money at that young age because of my work abroad. One time while I was on vacation in the Philippines, I saw a large billboard in EDSA ... Read more
blank

Income Tax Tables in the Philippines (2022)

The Philippines’ new tax reform bill, known as TRAIN or Tax Reform for Acceleration and Inclusion, was signed into law on December 19, 2017 and its implementation began on January 1, 2018. What are the new income tax rates under the TRAIN law? How will TRAIN affect income taxes of individuals and corporations? How is the ... Read more
blank

PSE Stocks Performance under each Philippine President (1987-2021)

Did you know that Philippine stocks were able to achieve an astounding growth of 800% in a span of 30 years? From 1987 until 2018, the Philippine Stock Exchange index (PSEi) rose from 1,000 points to a peak of 9,000 points — generating a return of 800% over 30 years. (The PSEi is an index ... Read more
blank

SSL 2022: Salary Increases for Teachers, Nurses, Gov’t Employees

Good news to all government employees! There’s a new round of salary increases beginning January 1, 2022! Millions of employees of the Philippine government — including public school teachers, nurses and staff of government hospitals, and workers in local and national government agencies, etc. — will be getting an automatic salary adjustment this 2022 under ... Read more
blank

PSE Trading Hours in 2022: What time open, when closed?

Before you take the plunge into stock trading and investing, make sure you understand what stocks are and how the Philippine Stock Exchange (PSE) operates. Unlike other investments that are relatively safe, stock trading is risky and loss of money is a possibility. So before you deep dive into the exciting world of stock trading, ... Read more

Price Floor and Price Ceiling of PSE Stocks

Trading bands in the PSE come in two forms: Price Ceiling, or the upper price limit, and Price Floor, or the lower price limit.

2 thoughts on “Can Royale Business Club survive tax evasion case?”

  1. Philippines is so popular of claiming tax, yet again mone claimed used for nothing or gov’t officials.. lol, marial law should be done to test all of us.

    Reply

Leave a Comment